Skip to Content

Bar Keepers Friend Vs Gumption (The Definitive Guide)

Have you ever found yourself in the cleaning aisle of your local store, staring at the endless array of multi-purpose cleansers? With so many options to choose from, it's easy to feel overwhelmed and unsure of which to buy. That's why we're here to help you settle the Bar Keepers Friend vs Gumption debate once and for all.

In this article, we'll compare the two leading brands in the multipurpose cleanser game and weigh up their pros and cons. From their cleaning power to their value for money, we'll cover it all so you can make an informed decision on which cleanser is best for you. So grab a cup of coffee and get ready to discover the ultimate cleaning champion.

Comparison

Ingredient Comparison

Effectiveness Comparison

Durability Comparison

Value Comparison

Multipurpose Cleanser

Final Verdict

This post contains affiliate links; as an Amazon Associate we earn commission from qualifying purchases.

Bar Keepers Friend Vs Gumption

Ingredient Comparison: Bar Keepers Friend vs Gumption

When it comes to cleaning products, it's important to know what you're using. That's why we're going to compare the ingredients of two popular cleaners, Bar Keepers Friend and Gumption, to help you make an informed decision.

Starting with the active ingredients, Bar Keepers Friend contains Oxalic Acid and Polishing Agents, while Gumption has Benzene Sulfonic Acid and Pumice. Oxalic acid is a mild acid that is effective in removing rust and stains, while polishing agents help to give surfaces a shine. Benzene sulfonic acid, on the other hand, is a stronger acid that is effective in removing grease and grime. Pumice is a natural abrasive that helps to scrub away dirt and stains.

When it comes to cleaning power, both cleaners are effective, but they have different strengths. Bar Keepers Friend is great for removing rust and hard water stains, while Gumption is better suited for removing tough stains like grease and grime. If you're looking for an all-purpose cleaner, Gumption might be the better choice, but if you have specific stains or areas you need to address, Bar Keepers Friend could be more effective.

Finally, let's talk about safety. Both cleaners contain harsh chemicals that can be harmful if ingested or used improperly. However, Bar Keepers Friend is a bit stronger and should be used with caution and proper ventilation. Gumption is a bit gentler and may be a better choice if you have pets or small children in your home.

In conclusion, when deciding between Bar Keepers Friend and Gumption, it's important to consider the ingredients, cleaning power, and safety. While both are great cleaners, the choice ultimately depends on your specific needs and preferences.

Effectiveness Comparison: Bar Keepers Friend vs Gumption

When it comes to household cleaners, it can be tough to decide which one to use for a particular cleaning job. Two popular options are Bar Keepers Friend and Gumption. Both claim to be effective at removing stains, grease, and grime, but which one is truly the best? We put them to the test on various surfaces commonly found in households.

First up, stainless steel. It's a popular choice for kitchen appliances, but can be a real pain to clean. We applied both Bar Keepers Friend and Gumption to some stainless steel surfaces with dried-on food stains and grease spots. After some elbow grease and a bit of a wait, both products managed to remove the stains fairly well, but Bar Keepers Friend was slightly better at tackling the grime.

Next, we moved onto porcelain, testing the cleaners on a dirty bathtub and basin. Once again, both products proved to be effective at removing dirt and stains. However, Gumption seemed to be slightly more effective at getting rid of hard water stains.

Finally, we tested the cleaners on plastic, specifically some outdoor furniture that had seen better days. This time, Bar Keepers Friend came out on top, effectively removing mould and mildew stains that Gumption struggled with.

Overall, both cleaners proved to be effective at tackling various types of dirt and stains. However, when it comes to stainless steel and plastic, Bar Keepers Friend seems to be slightly more effective, whereas Gumption shines when it comes to porcelain surfaces with hard water stains. It ultimately comes down to personal preference and the specific cleaning needs of your household.

Durability Comparison: Bar Keepers Friend vs Gumption

When it comes to cleaning products, durability is an important factor to consider. You don't want to be constantly replacing a product that doesn't hold up over time. That's why we're comparing the durability of Bar Keepers Friend and Gumption.

First, let's talk about how long each product lasts. Bar Keepers Friend comes in a powder form and a liquid form. The powder form can last for several months, depending on how often you use it. The liquid form may need to be replenished more frequently, but it still has a decent lifespan. Gumption comes in a paste form, which is prone to drying out over time. However, if you keep the lid tightly closed, it should last for a few months. Overall, both products are fairly long-lasting.

Next, let's consider how often you need to use them. Bar Keepers Friend is known for being a powerful cleaning agent that doesn't require a lot of elbow grease. You can use it sparingly and still get great results. Gumption, on the other hand, may require a bit more effort to get the job done. You also need to apply it more generously to achieve the desired effect. This means you may need to use more Gumption than Bar Keepers Friend over time, which can impact the overall value.

Finally, we'll look at how they store. Bar Keepers Friend can easily be stored in your cleaning cupboard or cabinet. The powder form takes up minimal space, and the liquid form comes in a compact bottle. Gumption, however, comes in a larger container due to its paste form. This can make it more difficult to store if you have limited space.

So, which one is a better value for your money in terms of durability? It really depends on your cleaning needs and habits. If you want a powerful, long-lasting cleaning product that requires minimal effort, Bar Keepers Friend may be the way to go. However, if you have particularly stubborn stains or you don't mind putting in some extra elbow grease, Gumption can also get the job done and is fairly long-lasting. Ultimately, both products have their pros and cons when it comes to durability, so it's up to you to decide which one works best for you.

Value Comparison: Bar Keepers Friend vs Gumption

When it comes to household cleaning products, finding one that is effective, durable, and affordable can be a challenge. Bar Keepers Friend and Gumption are two popular cleaning products that are highly regarded for their ability to clean tough stains and leave surfaces looking like new. But which one is a better value for your money?

Let's start by looking at the price. Bar Keepers Friend is typically sold at a slightly higher price point than Gumption, although this can vary depending on where you buy it. However, it's important to note that Bar Keepers Friend is more concentrated than Gumption, so you'll likely need less of it to achieve the same level of cleaning power.

When it comes to effectiveness, both products are highly effective at tackling tough stains and grime. Bar Keepers Friend is known for its ability to remove rust, hard water stains, and tarnish from metal surfaces like sinks and appliances. Gumption, on the other hand, is particularly effective at removing soap scum and grime from bathroom surfaces like tiles and shower screens.

Durability is also an important factor to consider when choosing a cleaning product. You want something that will last and not require frequent repurchases. Both Bar Keepers Friend and Gumption come in sturdy containers that can withstand regular use, so you won't have to worry about the products degrading over time. However, Bar Keepers Friend's more concentrated formula means that you'll likely use less of it overall, making it a more durable option in the long run.

So, which one is the better value for your money? It really depends on your cleaning needs. If you're dealing with a lot of metal surfaces that require polishing or removing tarnish, Bar Keepers Friend is an excellent choice. On the other hand, if you're looking for a versatile product that can clean a range of surfaces, Gumption is a great all-purpose option.

Ultimately, both Bar Keepers Friend and Gumption are excellent cleaning products that offer good value for their price. By considering your cleaning needs, you can make an informed decision about which one will work best for you.

Bar Keepers Friend Vs Gumption Multipurpose Cleanser

When it comes to finding the perfect multipurpose cleaner, there are many brands to choose from, each with its unique features and benefits. Here, we compare two popular brands: Bar Keepers Friend and Gumption. Using the reviewed products as examples, we'll highlight the strengths and weaknesses of each brand, making it easy for you to decide which one is right for you.

First up is Bar Keepers Friend. The BKF Cleanser is a powdered formula that has been around since 1882, and it's still going strong. One of the key benefits of the BKF Cleanser is its versatility. This product is tough enough to tackle even the most stubborn stains on non-porous surfaces, yet gentle enough to use on glass. It can eliminate rust, cut through tough grease, and restore shine to stainless steel and porcelain. Plus, it can be used to remove water spots, mineral deposits, and tarnish. The BKF Cleanser is suitable for use in the kitchen, bathroom, outdoors, and on vehicles and sporting equipment. It's a reliable choice for those tough cleaning tasks.

On the other hand, Gumption's Multi-Purpose Cleanser is a mild abrasive paste that has been loved for over 60 years. Like BKF, Gumption is effective at removing ingrained stains and grime, but it's also safe to use on most modern surfaces, including natural stone benchtops, laminates, baths, basins, tiles, stovetops, ovens, and stainless steel sinks. Unlike BKF, Gumption has a fresh lemon scent, so it leaves your home smelling great. One of the key selling points of Gumption is that it contains no bleaches or harsh chemicals, making it a safer option for those who are sensitive to chemicals.

When it comes down to it, both BKF and Gumption have their strengths. BKF is an excellent all-purpose cleaner that is tough on grime, but gentle enough to use on glassware. It's suitable for use in a wide range of situations, such as indoors and outdoors, and on vehicles and sporting equipment. Gumption, on the other hand, is safe to use on most modern surfaces around your home. It contains no bleaches or harsh chemicals, making it a popular choice for those with sensitive skin. Plus, the fresh lemon scent is a nice touch.

In conclusion, it's a matter of personal preference when it comes to choosing between BKF and Gumption. Both products have their unique features and benefits, and it really comes down to what you're looking for in a multipurpose cleaner. Consider your specific cleaning needs, and choose the product that best fits your needs.

Cleanser by Bar Keepers Friend, tough on grime, gentle on surfaces.

Cleanser by Bar Keepers Friend

Shop Check price on barkeepersfriend.com

Our rating: ★★★★★

Price: $$$$

Tough on grime, gentle on surfaces.

What makes it special? Bar Keepers Friend Cleanser is the go-to solution for tough cleaning tasks on non-porous surfaces. Its original 1882 formula powdered cleanser effectively removes stubborn rust, mineral deposits, grease, and tarnish from stainless steel, porcelain, and much more. It can also restore shine to uncoated surfaces. The cleanser formulation is tough on grime, yet gentle enough to use on glass. BKF Cleanser is suitable for use in bathrooms, kitchens, outdoors, and can tackle stains on vehicles, boats, and sporting equipment. However, users should test it first on delicate surfaces such as fiberglass, plastics, and anodized aluminum. Use BKF Cleanser and say goodbye to dirt, grime, and stubborn stains.

Find the best price on Bar Keepers Friend

Gumption 500g by Gumption, powerful and effective multi-purpose cleaner.

Gumption 500g by Gumption

Shop Check price on treatsfromoz.com

Our rating: ★★★★★

Price: $$$$

Powerful and effective multi-purpose cleaner.

What makes it special? Looking for a powerful and effective multi-purpose cleaner that won't damage your surfaces? Look no further than Gumption 500g. This mild abrasive paste has been loved for over 60 years for its ability to remove ingrained stains and dirt that ordinary cleaners can miss, revealing a stunning shine. And with no bleaches or harsh chemicals, you can feel good about using it on most old and modern surfaces around your home. Whether you're tackling natural stone benchtops, laminates, baths, basins, tiles, stovetops, ovens, or stainless steel sinks, Gumption gets the job done. Plus, it has a fresh lemon scent that leaves your entire home smelling great. Upgrade your cleaning game with Gumption and get ready to be amazed by the results!

Find the best price on Gumption

Final Verdict

In closing, it's clear that both Bar Keepers Friend and Gumption are incredibly powerful multipurpose cleaners. Each product offers its own unique array of benefits and drawbacks that can cater to different cleaning needs.

While Bar Keepers Friend seems to offer slightly superior results in removing tougher stains and restoring shine to metal surfaces; on the other hand, Gumption is gentle and versatile, perfect for a wide range of cleaning tasks, and can leave your surfaces lightly scented.

When it comes to value and durability, both brands have their pros and cons. Bar Keepers Friend comes in smaller containers but is capable of tackling most kitchen and bathroom cleaning tasks with minimal product needed, making it cost-effective. On the other hand, Gumption comes in larger containers at a lower price point and has a longer shelf life than Bar Keepers Friend.

At the end of the day, choosing between Bar Keepers Friend and Gumption comes down to personal preference and cleaning requirements. Therefore, it's fair to say that both brands are reliable choices for anyone looking to effectively clean their home. So, why not give both products a try and see which one works best for you?

Related articles

Bar Keeper's Friend vs Ajax (The Definitive Guide)

Bar Keeper's Friend vs Bon Ami (The Definitive Guide)

Bar Keeper's Friend vs Brasso (The Definitive Guide)

Bar Keeper's Friend vs Cif (The Definitive Guide)

Gumption vs Cif (The Definitive Guide)

Read more

Bar Keeper's Friend vs Comet (The Definitive Guide)

Bar Keeper's Friend vs Soft Scrub (The Definitive Guide)