Skip to Content

Bar Keepers Friend Vs Soft Scrub (The Definitive Guide)

Are you tired of constantly battling tough stains and grime in your home? Then it's time to call in the big guns of the cleaning world: Bar Keepers Friend and Soft Scrub. These two beloved household cleansers have been duking it out for years, but which one will come out on top?

In this article, we're going to break down the key differences and similarities between Bar Keepers Friend and Soft Scrub, giving you the ultimate guide to choosing the best cleanser for your needs. So buckle up and get ready to clean house like a pro!

Comparison

Ingredients Comparison

Cleaning Power Comparison

Ease of Use Comparison

Cost Comparison

Soft Scrub All Purpose Cleanser and the BKF (Bar Keepers Friend) Soft Cleanser

Final Verdict

This post contains affiliate links; as an Amazon Associate we earn commission from qualifying purchases.

Bar Keepers Friend Vs Soft Scrub

Ingredients Comparison: Bar Keepers Friend Vs Soft Scrub

When it comes to cleaning products, two of the most popular and trusted brands are Bar Keepers Friend and Soft Scrub. Both of these brands claim to be tough on stains and grime, but which one is better? To find out, let's take a closer look at their ingredients and see which one comes out on top.

First, let's start with Bar Keepers Friend. This product contains oxalic acid, which is a powerful cleaning agent that is great for removing tough stains and rust. In addition, Bar Keepers Friend also contains sodium chloride and detergent, which can help to dissolve grease and other stubborn substances. Overall, the combination of these ingredients makes Bar Keepers Friend an effective and reliable cleaning product for a wide range of surfaces.

Now, let's move on to Soft Scrub. This product also contains some powerful cleaning agents, including sodium hypochlorite and sodium hydroxide. These ingredients are known for their ability to remove stains and disinfect surfaces. However, Soft Scrub also contains a variety of other ingredients, such as fragrance, dye, and preservatives. While these ingredients may not have a direct impact on the cleaning power of the product, they can make it less environmentally friendly and potentially irritating to the skin.

So, which one is better for you? Ultimately, it depends on your specific cleaning needs and preferences. If you're looking for a product that is strong yet gentle on surfaces, Bar Keepers Friend is a great choice. However, if you're looking for a disinfecting cleaner that contains bleach, Soft Scrub may be more suitable. Regardless of which one you choose, both of these cleaning products are effective and offer good value for money.

Cleaning Power Comparison: Bar Keepers Friend Vs Soft Scrub

When it comes to tough cleaning jobs, Bar Keepers Friend and Soft Scrub are two of the most popular products out there. Both are known for their ability to tackle stubborn stains and grime, but which one is more effective? In this section, we'll take a closer look at the cleaning power of Bar Keepers Friend vs Soft Scrub.

First up, let's talk about Bar Keepers Friend. This product has been around for over a century, and it's still one of the go-to cleaners for many people. One of the key advantages of Bar Keepers Friend is its ability to remove rust and hard water stains, which can be some of the toughest to get rid of. Whether you're scrubbing your sink or your bathroom tiles, Bar Keepers Friend can help to break down and dissolve mineral build-up.

Soft Scrub, on the other hand, is a more recent arrival on the cleaning scene. It's a cream cleanser that's specifically designed to be gentle on surfaces while still providing powerful cleaning action. Soft Scrub is great at removing grease and grime, especially in the kitchen. If you've got a sticky, greasy mess on your counters or stovetop, Soft Scrub can help to cut through it without damaging the surface.

So, which product is more effective overall? It really depends on the type of cleaning job you're tackling. If you're dealing with rust or hard water stains, Bar Keepers Friend is likely to be your best bet. On the other hand, if you're dealing with grease or grime, Soft Scrub is probably going to be your go-to. Ultimately, both products have their strengths and weaknesses, and the best one for you will depend on your specific needs.

In conclusion, both Bar Keepers Friend and Soft Scrub are powerful cleaning products that can get the job done. When it comes to choosing between the two, it's important to consider what type of cleaning you'll be doing and which product is best suited for that task. Whether you're cleaning your kitchen, bathroom, or any other area of your home, these two products are sure to help you get the job done.

Ease of Use Comparison: Bar Keepers Friend Vs Soft Scrub

When it comes to cleaning products, ease of use is a major factor that we all consider. Nobody wants to spend hours scrubbing away at tough stains and grime, so we need something that's quick and effective. In this section, we'll compare the ease of use of Bar Keepers Friend and Soft Scrub, including their application methods, and any potential safety concerns.

Let's start with application methods. Both products are easy to use, but they differ in terms of their texture. Bar Keepers Friend comes in a powder form, whereas Soft Scrub is a creamy liquid. This means that Bar Keepers Friend can be a bit messier to apply, as there is a risk of the powder spilling and dispersing everywhere. On the other hand, Soft Scrub is easy to apply neatly and precisely.

Next up is scent. Both products have a distinct smell, but again, they differ in their intensity and nature. Bar Keepers Friend has a strong, chemical smell that is not particularly pleasant. Soft Scrub, however, has a milder, more pleasant scent that is much easier to tolerate. So, if you're sensitive to strong smells, Soft Scrub might be the better option.

Finally, we come to safety concerns. Both products are relatively safe to use, but Bar Keepers Friend can be a bit more hazardous if not used correctly. Exposure to the powder can cause irritation to the eyes, nose, and throat, so it's important to wear protective gear such as gloves and a mask when using it. Soft Scrub is generally safer, but it should still be used in a well-ventilated area to avoid breathing in any harmful fumes.

In conclusion, both Bar Keepers Friend and Soft Scrub are relatively easy to use, but they differ in their texture, scent, and potential safety concerns. If you prioritize ease of use and a mild scent, Soft Scrub might be the better option. However, if you need something that can tackle tough stains and grime, Bar Keepers Friend is the way to go. Just be sure to use it safely!

Cost Comparison: Bar Keepers Friend Vs Soft Scrub

When it comes to cleaning products, there are plenty of options on the market. Two of the most popular are Bar Keepers Friend and Soft Scrub. Both products promise to get your home sparkling clean, but which one provides the best value for your money? Let's take a closer look at the cost comparison of Bar Keepers Friend vs Soft Scrub.

Bar Keepers Friend is a powdered cleanser that comes in a 21 oz canister. The average cost for a canister is around $4-5, depending on where you purchase it. When using Bar Keepers Friend, you only need a small amount to get the job done. This means that one canister can last you a few months, depending on how often you use it.

Soft Scrub, on the other hand, comes in a variety of forms including powder, foam, and gel. The average cost for a bottle of Soft Scrub is around $3-4, again depending on where you purchase it. Soft Scrub tends to require a bit more product to get the job done, so you may go through a bottle more quickly than you would a canister of Bar Keepers Friend.

In terms of price per use, Bar Keepers Friend comes out on top. With its concentrated formula, you just need a small amount to tackle even the toughest messes. Soft Scrub, while still an effective cleaner, requires more product to get the same results. This means you may end up spending more money in the long run if you choose Soft Scrub over Bar Keepers Friend.

When it comes to choosing between Bar Keepers Friend and Soft Scrub, it really comes down to personal preference. However, from a cost perspective, Bar Keepers Friend is the better value for your money. With its concentrated formula and longer shelf life, you'll spend less money over time and still get the same great results. So next time you're in the cleaning aisle, give Bar Keepers Friend a try and see for yourself why it's worth the few extra dollars.

Bar Keepers Friend Vs Soft Scrub Soft Scrub All Purpose Cleanser and the BKF (Bar Keepers Friend) Soft Cleanser

When it comes to household cleaning, Soft Scrub and Bar Keepers Friend (BKF) are two popular brands with a range of effective products. Both brands offer all-purpose cleansers to help make cleaning easier and more efficient. Let's delve deeper into the Soft Scrub All Purpose Cleanser and the BKF Soft Cleanser to see how these products compare.

The Soft Scrub All Purpose Cleanser is a powerful cleaning solution that is perfect for tough stains on sinks, showers, and toilets. This particular product has an improved formula that packs more cleaning punch in a faster and easier to rinse formula, and is available in two sizes - 24oz and 36oz. The product also leaves behind a fresh lemon scent, which is a nice touch. The all-purpose cleanser is ideal for use on a variety of surfaces such as bathtubs, countertops, stovetops, and tiles. Additionally, the product is Orthodox Union certified Kosher, which may put some consumers at ease as it's likely to be safer for their families.

On the other hand, the BKF Soft Cleanser is a premixed, creamy solution for quick cleaning tasks that delivers the same power as their classic Cleanser. It has the same signature look as the bar-shaped cleanser. This particular product is ideal for cleaning glass shower doors due to its exceptional clinging properties. The cleanser effectively removes soap scum, rust stains, tarnish, and mineral deposits from a variety of surfaces such as stainless steel, brass, bronze, ceramic, porcelain, glass, and Corian. According to its label, the Soft Cleanser should not be overused as it may etch or dull delicate surfaces. Also, some of its ingredients may etch delicate surfaces, thus users must test it on a small area before use.

When it comes to deciding between these two brands, it ultimately comes down to personal preference and the particular surface that needs cleaning. While both products work well on a range of surfaces, the Soft Scrub All Purpose Cleanser has the added advantage of being kosher certified, as well as providing a fresh lemon scent. In contrast, the BKF Soft Cleanser's strong clinging properties make it more effective for cleaning glass surfaces and other tricky to clean surfaces than the All Purpose Soft Scrub Cleanser.

Overall, both the Soft Scrub All Purpose Cleanser and the BKF Soft Cleanser are excellent all-purpose cleaning solutions. Choosing between the two brands depends on the specific surface that needs cleaning and the personal preferences of the consumer.

Soft Cleanser by Bar Keepers Friend, quickly cleans tough stains on any surface.

Soft Cleanser by Bar Keepers Friend

Shop Check price on barkeepersfriend.com

Our rating: ★★★★★

Price: $$$$

Quickly cleans tough stains on any surface.

What makes it special? Bar Keepers Friend Soft Cleanser is a premixed, creamy solution for quick cleaning tasks that delivers the same power as their classic Cleanser. The exceptional clinging properties make it ideal for vertical surfaces, including glass shower doors that frequently accumulate soap scum, rust stains, tarnish, and mineral deposits. This liquid cleaner is also ideal for use on stainless steel, brass, bronze, ceramic, porcelain, glass, and Corian® surfaces. As per the directions, a little goes a long way, and less product should be used than expected. In addition, the product should not be overused, as it may etch or dull delicate surfaces. Despite its remarkable efficiency, it is gentle enough to use on various surfaces and is safe for septic systems. This product is perfect for anyone looking for an effective and easy-to-use cleaning solution.

Find the best price on Bar Keepers Friend

Soft Scrub® All Purpose Cleanser by Soft Scrub, powerful, efficient cleaner for tough stains and soils.

Soft Scrub® All Purpose Cleanser by Soft Scrub

Shop Check price on softscrub.com

Our rating: ★★★★★

Price: $$$$

Powerful, efficient cleaner for tough stains and soils.

What makes it special? Soft Scrub® All Purpose Cleanser is a powerful cleaner that is perfect for tough stains on sinks, showers, and toilets. This improved formula is faster and easier to rinse, making cleaning a breeze. The lemon scent that it leaves behind is refreshing too. It is also Orthodox Union certified Kosher, making it a safer cleaning option for families. This product can be used on multiple surfaces including bathtubs, countertops, stovetops, and tiles. It is also effective at removing greasy soils. To use, simply squeeze onto tough stains or onto a damp sponge, rub, and rinse or wipe clean. Soft Scrub has a range of multi-purpose cleaning products but the All Purpose Cleanser is definitely a standout. It is a must-have for anyone looking for a powerful and efficient solution to their cleaning needs.

Find the best price on Soft Scrub

Final Verdict

In conclusion, the debate about Bar Keepers Friend versus Soft Scrub will likely never be settled. While each product has its unique strengths, ultimately the choice depends on your personal preferences.

Bar Keepers Friend offers a slightly more abrasive formula and is ideal for tackling tough stains on surfaces like stainless steel and ceramics. However, if you don't require that level of grit, Soft Scrub may be the better option - it's gentler on surfaces like fiberglass and acrylics.

When it comes to price, both products are affordable and offer excellent value for money. Bar Keepers Friend may be slightly more expensive, but considering its effectiveness, it's worth the investment. Meanwhile, Soft Scrub's versatility and ease of use make it an attractive option for those who like a no-fuss approach to cleaning.

At the end of the day, it's important to note that both cleaners are effective, safe, and trusted brands. Whether you choose Bar Keepers Friend or Soft Scrub, you can rest assured that you're using a quality product that will get the job done.

Related articles

Bar Keeper's Friend vs Ajax (The Definitive Guide)

Bar Keeper's Friend vs Comet (The Definitive Guide)

Bar Keeper's Friend vs Bon Ami (The Definitive Guide)

Bar Keeper's Friend vs Brasso (The Definitive Guide)

Bar Keeper's Friend vs Cif (The Definitive Guide)

Read more

Bar Keeper's Friend vs Gumption (The Definitive Guide)

Biokleen vs Seventh Generation (The Definitive Guide)