Skip to Content

Charmin Vs Cottonelle (The Definitive Guide)

Are you tired of searching for the perfect toilet paper? Aisle after aisle, it can be overwhelming to choose one brand over another. But fear not, we're here to help you compare Charmin vs Cottonelle. Sure, they both claim to be soft, strong, and absorbent, but which one is really better? Is Charmin's thickness worth the extra penny or should you opt for Cottonelle's eco-friendly option? And let's not forget about the number of plys and sheets per roll.

In this article, we'll break down the key differences and similarities between these two brands and determine the ultimate winner. So, grab a cup of coffee, sit back, and let's find out which toilet paper reigns supreme.


Ply Count




Toilet Paper

Final Verdict

This post contains affiliate links; as an Amazon Associate we earn commission from qualifying purchases.

Charmin Vs Cottonelle

Charmin Vs Cottonelle: Which brand has more ply?

When it comes to buying toilet paper, one question that often comes to mind is, which brand has more ply? Charmin or Cottonelle? To make an informed decision, it's essential to understand the differences between the two.

Charmin is known for its thick and ultra-soft paper, which is perfect for those who want a luxurious feel while using it. Their Ultra Soft toilet paper comes with two layers of cushiony comfort, making it suitable for people with sensitive skin.

On the other hand, Cottonelle offers a variety of toilet paper products with different ply options. Their CleanCare brand boasts of having four layers of strength, making it ideal for households with multiple users or frequent visitors.

But, if you're looking for softness and thickness in one package, Cottonelle Ultra Comfort Care might be worth trying. It has two layers of softness coupled with an extra-absorbent material that ensures a comfortable and clean feeling.

So, which brand has more ply? It depends on what you're looking for. If you want a more luxurious feel, Charmin could be the perfect fit for you. However, if you're looking for strength and durability, Cottonelle could be a better choice.

In conclusion, it's all about personal preference and comfort. Both Charmin and Cottonelle have their strengths and weaknesses, but deciding which one is better ultimately depends on your needs. It's best to try both brands and see which one suits you best.

Charmin Vs Cottonelle: Which brand is more cost-effective?

When it comes to choosing the perfect toilet paper brand for your home, budget and family size are important factors to consider. As we pit Charmin against Cottonelle in terms of cost-effectiveness, we’re going to give you a lowdown on the pricing differences between the two brands.

Generally, Charmin and Cottonelle offer various options for different budgets. Charmin Ultra Soft toilet paper prices range from $9.99 for a 12-roll pack to $34.99 for a 36-roll pack. Meanwhile, Cottonelle Ultra Comfort Care’s prices range from $9.99 for a 12-roll pack to $30.99 for a 36-roll pack.

While cost per roll may differ between the two brands, it’s essential to factor in the number of sheets per roll too. Charmin’s Ultra Soft toilet paper boasts 338 sheets per roll, while Cottonelle’s Ultra Comfort Care provides 326 sheets per roll.

Overall, Charmin is slightly more expensive than Cottonelle. However, if you’re looking for a more budget-friendly option, there are a variety of Charmin products that come at lower prices. When it comes to family size, both brands have a range of options for families both big and small.

If you're on a tight budget, Cottonelle is a more cost-effective option. However, if you’re looking for a luxury feel combined with strength and durability, Charmin is the clear winner despite being a bit more expensive.

When it comes to making the decision on the perfect toilet paper brand for your home, you’ll want to consider both your budget and family size. Ultimately, the choice between Charmin and Cottonelle boils down to personal preferences and needs. So, based on your budget and family size, choose the perfect option for you.

Charmin Vs Cottonelle: Which brand is more eco-friendly?

When it comes to sustainability, every little decision counts. Even the toilet paper we choose can have an impact on the environment. So, which brand - Charmin or Cottonelle - is more eco-friendly?

Let's start with Charmin. The brand claims to be committed to sustainability, but what does that actually mean? Well, they have made some improvements in recent years such as sourcing their materials from responsibly managed forests, reducing waste during manufacturing, and using renewable energy sources. However, they still use bleaching agents and other chemicals in their production process that can be harmful to the environment. Plus, they do not have any certification from independent organizations that verify their sustainability, which raises some questions.

On the other hand, Cottonelle has taken some serious steps towards eco-friendliness. For example, they have partnered with the World Wildlife Fund to promote sustainable forestry practices and are completely free of bleach and other harsh chemicals in their paper production. They have also obtained certifications from third-party organizations, such as the Forest Stewardship Council (FSC) and the Sustainable Forestry Initiative (SFI), that verify their sustainability claims.

In terms of their packaging, both brands offer recyclable options, but Cottonelle's packages are made from 100% recycled content, whereas Charmin's packages are only made from 10% recycled content.

So, while Charmin has taken some steps towards sustainability, Cottonelle seems to have a more robust eco-friendly plan in place. From their partnerships with environmental organizations to their chemical-free production and sustainable forestry practices, Cottonelle comes out on top as the more eco-friendly option.

When deciding which brand to choose, it's important to consider the impact we have as consumers and choose brands that align with our values. For those who prioritize environmental sustainability, Cottonelle may be the better choice.

Charmin Vs Cottonelle: Consumer preferences

When it comes to choosing between Charmin and Cottonelle, consumer preferences can vary depending on individual experiences and opinions. In this section, we'll explore what people have to say about these two popular toilet paper brands.

Many users of Charmin swear by its softness and thickness, claiming that it provides a comfortable and reliable clean. On the other hand, Cottonelle fans love the brand's unique texture, which is designed to remove more per wipe compared to other leading brands.

Consumers also have differing opinions about the durability of Charmin and Cottonelle. Some users have reported that Charmin tends to shred when wet, while others have found the opposite to be true. Cottonelle, on the other hand, has received praise for its strength and ability to hold up even when wet.

When it comes to scent and color, Charmin and Cottonelle offer different options for consumers. While Charmin has a variety of fragrances to choose from, many people prefer Cottonelle's unscented option for a more natural and fresh clean.

Ultimately, the choice between Charmin and Cottonelle comes down to personal preference. Some people prioritize softness and comfort, while others prioritize strength and durability. Whichever brand you choose, it's important to consider your own needs and preferences when deciding.

Charmin Vs Cottonelle Toilet Paper

When it comes to choosing toilet paper, two popular brands that come to mind are Charmin and Cottonelle. Both brands offer a wide range of toilet paper products, but how do they compare? Let's take a look at their offerings using their reviewed products to represent each brand.

Charmin's Ultra Soft Super Mega Roll is an incredibly soft 2-ply toilet paper that is perfect for those who value comfort above all else. Its wavy edge innovation ensures a smooth tear, while its 2x absorbency allows you to use less. Additionally, Charmin's Super Mega Roll lasts longer and is a great value for your money, with one roll equaling six regular rolls. Charmin takes pride in its commitment to sustainability and responsible forestry practices, thus ensuring that their products are both eco-friendly and high-quality.

On the other hand, Cottonelle's Ultra Clean Toilet Paper is designed for cleaning with a unique CleaningRipples™ texture that removes residue more efficiently and helps ensure a confident clean. It is 3x thicker, 3x stronger, and 2x more absorbent than the leading national value brand. Cottonelle's Ultra Clean is also septic safe and flushable, meaning that you can use it with confidence. Like Charmin, Cottonelle is a brand that takes sustainability seriously and uses responsibly sourced fibers in all of its products.

In comparing the two brands, Charmin's Ultra Soft Super Mega Roll prioritizes comfort and softness while still maintaining eco-friendliness. Cottonelle's Ultra Clean Toilet Paper, on the other hand, prioritizes efficiency while still ensuring it is septic safe and flushable. Ultimately, it comes down to personal preference and what you prioritize more – comfort or cleaning efficiency. Both brands offer a range of products in different sizes and counts to suit different needs.

In conclusion, when it comes to choosing between Charmin and Cottonelle, it is good to know that both brands have a commitment to sustainability and responsible forestry practices. However, the real decision-maker comes down to individual preferences, as both brands offer high-quality toilet paper products that vary in softness and efficiency. Nevertheless, with the information provided, you can make a well-informed decision and decide which brand offers the toilet paper that best suits your needs.

ULTRA SOFT SUPER MEGA ROLL by Charmin, soft, strong, and long-lasting toilet paper.


Shop Check price on

Our rating: ★★★★★

Price: $$$$+

Soft, strong, and long-lasting toilet paper.

What makes it special? Charmin’s Ultra Soft Super Mega Roll is a must-try for anyone seeking an irresistibly soft toilet paper that lasts longer. It is Charmin’s softest 2-ply toilet paper ever made, with comfort cushions that you can both feel and see. Furthermore, it is 2X more absorbent than the leading bargain brand, so you can use less and save more. Plus, it is clog-safe and septic-safe, and approved by Roto-Rooter plumbers who prefer Charmin over any other brand. And with its wavy edge innovation, the roll is easier than ever to tear. With one Charmin Super Mega Roll equaling six regular Charmin rolls and its guaranteed fit, it’s a great value for your money. Enjoy the go with Charmin’s Ultra Soft Super Mega Roll and keep our forests healthy with their sustainability commitment.

Find the best price on Charmin

Cottonelle® Ultra Clean Toilet Paper by Cottonelle, efficient, strong, and eco-friendly toilet paper.

Cottonelle® Ultra Clean Toilet Paper by Cottonelle

Shop Check price on

Our rating: ★★★★★

Price: $$$$

Efficient, strong, and eco-friendly toilet paper.

What makes it special? Cottonelle® Ultra Clean Toilet Paper is a game-changer in the toiletries aisle. The unique CleaningRipples™ texture helps clean more efficiently and confidently. This 1-layer toilet paper is 3X thicker, 3X stronger, and 2X more absorbent than the leading national value brand. Cottonelle® takes environmental responsibility seriously, sourcing fibers from sustainable forests and promoting forest management to avoid biodiversity harm. Their products are 100% flushable, safe for sewers, and septic-tank-friendly, making them a worry-free option for daily use. Customers can choose from a variety of bulk pack sizes, from a 4-count set to a 36-count set. Besides, this product can also be paired with flushable wipes for a refreshing, luxurious clean. Overall, Cottonelle® Ultra Clean Toilet Paper delivers exceptional quality and eco-friendliness.

Find the best price on Cottonelle

Final Verdict

When it comes to choosing between Charmin and Cottonelle, there are various factors worth considering, including price, eco-friendliness, and the number of sheets per roll. However, it is important to note that both of these brands have their unique strengths, and ultimately, the better choice depends on your personal preferences.

Let's start with the price. While Charmin tends to be pricier per roll, it often has more sheets per roll than Cottonelle, which may balance out the cost. Additionally, Charmin's higher quality paper may result in using less in the long run, thus making it a more cost-effective option.

When it comes to eco-friendliness, both brands are making strides towards sustainability. Charmin offers a line of toilet paper made from responsibly sourced, renewable materials, while Cottonelle has committed to using 100% plant-based fibers in all their products by 2022. For those concerned about environmental impact, either brand is a good choice.

The number of sheets per roll is another factor to consider. For those who want to reduce waste and save money, Cottonelle may be the way to go since it typically has fewer sheets per roll, which can result in less waste. On the other hand, Charmin's larger rolls may mean fewer trips to the store and less hassle with changing out the roll.

When it comes down to it, which brand you choose comes down to your personal preferences. Some people prefer the softness of Charmin's pillows while others prefer the slightly rougher texture of Cottonelle's products. It is essential to note that both Charmin and Cottonelle have been around for years and are both solid options. You can rest assured that you won't make a wrong decision in choosing either of these top-quality brands.

In conclusion, whether you're looking for more sheets per roll or a more eco-friendly option, both Charmin and Cottonelle have a lot to offer. Instead of pitting them against each other, let's appreciate these brands for their respective strengths and choose which one suits our unique needs. The bottom line is - there is no clear winner, just personal preference.

Read more

Charmin vs Angel Soft (The Definitive Guide)

Charmin vs Quilted Northern (The Definitive Guide)